Young people sitting on a bench

The Milburn Review – implications for Scotland

Reading Time: 6 minutes

Alan Milburn published his report on young people not in education, employment or training on Tuesday 17 November. It sets out a radical redesign of support for young people taking in social security, education, skills, health and employment support.

What does this mean for Scotland where these proposals cut across a complex mix of reserved and devolved policy?

What has the Milburn review proposed?

Key proposals for public services include:

  • A local Youth Opportunity Service for England, to deliver
    • An ‘Opportunity Guarantee’ – a statutory entitlement to a route to education, training or work.
    • A ‘Support Guarantee ‘- a statutory entitlement to the ‘health, employment, functional and practical help young people need.’
  • Education, training and health reform in England.
  • A radical overhaul of social security for young people. The proposed changes to Universal Credit would apply across Great Britain, but the proposed changes to Personal Independence Payment (PIP) would not apply in Scotland.

These are not small changes. Milburn describes his proposals to: “create an entirely new benefit system for young people.”

The social security changes propose replacing two existing benefits with new payments for young people under 25 (para 732).

  • Universal Credit – which is reserved, would be replaced across Great Britain by:
    • a ‘Youth Allowance’ and
    • a local, flexible ‘Health and Disability Fund’ to contribute to ‘extra costs.’
  • Personal Independence Payment – which is devolved and has been replaced in Scotland by Adult Disability Payment – will be replaced in England and Wales by:
    • A ‘new ‘Additional Costs Allowance’ payment for those under 25, which will be ‘more closely targeted at those with demonstrable extra costs.’
    • A new ‘Severe and Complex Needs Insurance’ for those with the most profound and long-term disabilities who are unlikely to ever be able to work.
    • Extending Child Disability Living Allowance to age 18, implying that these new payments will start at 18 rather than 16 (the Scottish equivalent Child Disability Payment already supports young people up to age 18).

The report does admit that the: “Detailed gateway design needed for these changes will require further work.”

When will this happen?

The report states that: “This is a 10 year plan, not a one year sprint.”

Under the proposals, phased roll-out would start ‘within the lifetime of this Parliament’ and welfare savings would be expected to start from 2029-30 (para 742).

Crucially, a key principle is that the proposed approach would:

“not reduce existing financial help before the replacement support and opportunity are in place.” (para 767)

The new multi-disciplinary Youth Opportunity Service would be phased in, and available across England by 2029. Once the support and opportunity guarantees are in place locally, new claims would start on the new benefits system and existing claimants would be moved across to the new system when their scheduled reassessment are due. (para 733, 769, 770)

This raises the question of whether the timing of the changes to Universal Credit in Scotland might be affected by whether sufficient progress has been made in providing a devolved equivalent to the Youth Opportunity Service. This suggests there is much to be discussed between the UK and Scottish Governments that goes far beyond the mechanics of Barnett consequentials and Block Grant Adjustments.

On the other hand, the report suggests that:

“Government should be ambitious about the pace of transition and set a maximum period of no more than 5 years to complete rollout.” (para 773).

Financial implications for the Scottish Government

There is very little detail on costings in the report that provides any clues for the potential impact on the Scottish budget. It says an:

“initial £500 million investment should be made available for 2027/28 by reprioritising existing spending. This should fund enhanced employment and mental health support and expanded work placement, college and apprenticeship places”

The focus is on re-prioritisation rather than new funding. The extent of Barnett consequentials will depend on where spending is re-prioritised from.

Welfare savings are expected from 2029-30, but there is no breakdown of the savings expected from changes to PIP compared to changes to Universal Credit. This makes is difficult to assess what the implications would be for the Scottish block grant, which would be affected by the changes to PIP but not the changes to Universal Credit.

Instead of PIP, people in Scotland get Adult Disability Payment (ADP).

This year, the Scottish Government is forecast to pay out £209 million more in Adult Disability Payment than it received in funding through the PIP Block Grant Adjustment. In the absence of any reforms this difference is expected to increase to around £290 million by 2030.

There are 36,555 people under 25 getting ADP this year. That’s 7% of the total caseload. We don’t know how much ADP people under 25 are getting but 7% of the total spend on ADP this year is around £270 million. However, the actual reduction in block grant is likely to be considerably less than this, depending on how many disabled young people in England and Wales qualify for the new ‘extra costs’ and ‘severe and complex need insurance’.

Yet another imponderable is the status of the new ‘health and disability fund’ that would replace the Universal Credit additional ‘health’ payment. This ‘flexible’, ‘personalised’ award would be distributed through the Youth Opportunity Service suggesting it will be local and discretionary rather than a social security payment based on entitlements. This means it’s not at all clear how it would apply in Scotland.

How many people in Scotland will the changes to Universal Credit affect?

In June 2026 there were nearly 25,000 young people getting the Universal Credit ‘health element’. These are young people assessed through the ‘Work Capability Assessment (WCA) as having ‘limited capability for work’ (LCW). Of these, over 17,000 were getting an additional payment because they have have ‘Limited Capability for Work Related Activity’ (LCWRA) (Source: DWP StatXplore).

Since April 2026 this LCWRA additional payment has already been reduced for new claimants unless they meet certain exceptions such as having a severe condition or terminal illness. Under the Milburn proposals it would be removed entirely. They would get a new Youth Allowance set at the Universal Credit under 25 rate. Health support would be provided through other means.

Universal Credit, ‘health element’ awards for people under 25 in Scotland, June 2026 (Source, DWP StatXplore).

Universal Credit assessment
Non Severe Condition
Severe Condition
Total
Pre-WCA
3,938
0
3,938
LCW
3,425
0
3,425
LCWRA
15,878
1,654
17,532
Total
23,239
1,654
24,896

How does the report recognise devolution?

The report makes much of the proposals in England for further devolution to local government, but does not discuss in any detail existing devolution to Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.

It asks each devolved nation to consider how the underlying principles of the review:

“fit its own institutions and existing youth, careers and employment services.”

The report asks for co-operation between the UK and devolved governments:

“Progress in England alone cannot deliver a UK-wide ambition. The UK government and devolved governments should agree common definitions, a shared set of headline outcomes and a regular joint review of progress, while responsibility for the means remains devolved. They should also discuss if further decentralisation or alignment of reserved youth employment support would better match powers with accountability in each nation.”

Scottish employabilty support

Employability support is partly reserved and partly devolved although the Milburn report raises the possibility of further devolution.

Most devolved Scottish employability support is provided via local authorities through the ‘No-one Left Behind’ framework. Latest statistics show that, in 2025-26 there were just over 10,000 people aged under 25 in Scotland participating in ‘No-one Left Behind’.

Of these, 3,696 were disabled or had a long-term health condition. We don’t know what the overlap is with the nearly 25,000 young people on Universal Credit ‘health’ element or the 36,000 young people getting ADP. However, it is clear that many more disabled young people get ADP than get UC-health-related payments and many more young people are getting UC-health-related payments than are getting devolved employability support.

Some young people getting ADP will be in education, training or employment but we don’t know how many.

The Milburn proposals are based on balancing a radical overhaul of social security with an ambitious expansion of support at a local level. It is not at all clear how well that vision fits with what is available in Scotland, which has its own reforms to apprenticeships and has launched its own review of employability services.

Youth employment and training in Scotland

Researchers at the Scottish Health Equity Research Unit have discussed how, despite the lack of comparable data for Scotland, many of the issues raised in the Milburn Review are likely to be similar:

“In Scotland, many of the concerns voiced in the Milburn review ring true, although we find a potentially less dire situation for youth participation, which has improved over time, albeit the data is either unreliable or not directly comparable to the UK figure.”

Asked in September what the Scottish Government was doing for young people not in education, employment or training, Tom Arthur, Minister for Business and Fair Work, said:

“Our Programme for Government commits to funding 150,000 apprenticeships over this parliament, expanding work-based learning, reviewing employability services all of which will be of benefit to our Young People.” (S7W-03156 answered 21 September 2026)

The Scottish Parliament’s Education and Young People Committee is currently undertaking an inquiry into apprenticeships. This includes looking at Scottish Government reforms to apprenticeships.

During Session 6, the Scottish Government legislated to give the Scottish Funding Council (the SFC) new responsibilities for apprenticeships. The SFC is expected to take these up from April 2027. Reforms to reduce the complexity of the apprenticeship system are expected to follow.

Time to plan

The Milburn reforms have yet to be legislated for and – if passed by the UK Parliament – will be phased in over several years. The Scottish Government will need to decide whether it will continue to fund ADP as is, whether it will seek to match the level of employability support for young people proposed through the Youth Opportunity Service for England and how it will use additional any Barnett consequentials which will be generated by these reforms. There will also be the issue of how any PIP reforms impact on the block grant adjustment for social security and whether changes to ADP in Scotland are in line with these adjustments.

More reforms to come

The Timms review, expected by the end of November is expected to make further proposals to reform Personal Independence Payment, affecting all age-groups. These could further affect the amount of money transferred to Scotland via the PIP Block Grant Adjustment.

Camilla Kidner, Senior Researcher, Social Security